USA Insider Exclusive

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive show news, updates, and more!

Sign Up For Free to View
USA Insider Love Island

Who Won Every Season of Love Island USA?

Finding love on an island and taking home the grand prize is the dream. Here's a look at the past winners of Love Island USA

By Shameika Rhymes
Love Island Usa Winners

The fifth season of Love Island USA is underway and we’re still weeks away from finding out who will take home the coveted $100,000 grand prize. But what does it take for someone to take home the show's grand prize? Fortunately, we can look to the past to get an idea of who will ultimately be standing tall in the end.

How to Watch

Watch Temptation Island on the USA app and Peacock.

While fans cast their votes leading up to the crowning of this season’s winner, here’s a look back at who won the prior seasons of Love Island USA and where they are now.

Love Island Usa Winners

Who won Love Island USA Season 4?

The fourth season of Love Island USA crowned fan favorites Zeta Morrison and Timmy Pandolfi as the winners.

Morrison was a model and nanny from Los Angeles, and Pandolfi was a real estate agent and personal trainer also from L.A. They coupled up at the beginning of the season and stayed strong despite all of the challenges and temptations. Sadly, Zimmy didn’t make it too much longer after they left the island together. Zeta revealed in a podcast that their relationship crumbled due to a lack of communication. Timmy on the other hand shared with TMZ that the romance started stalling out after the cameras stopped rolling. 

Love Island Usa Winners

Who won Love Island USA Season 3?

Korey Gandy & Olivia Kaiser ended up winning the entire third season taking home the grand prize and a loving relationship.

However, things didn’t last too much longer after the show ended. Korey announced on social media that he was grateful for the time they shared, but it was a mutual decision to part ways because they lost the idyllic setting of the show and had to face real life struggles. Both ended up thriving in their careers as influencers; Korey on OnlyFans while Olivia has a beauty and skincare line, plus she appeared on Season 38 of MTV’s “The Challenge.”

Love Island Usa Winners

Who won Love Island USA Season 2?

Season 2 couple Justine Ndiba and Caleb Corprew were fan favorites and took home the $100,000.

Justine was a part of the original cast from the beginning and Caleb came in on the fifth day. They were together from that point on. While others struggled, they managed to hang onto each other. They were also the first Black couple to ever win Love Island USA! Sadly, they went their separate ways in 2021. 

Love Island Usa Winners

Who won Love Island USA Season 1?

Given their connection from the beginning of Love Island USA Season 1, it was no surprise that Zac Mirabelli and Elizabeth Wheeler won the reality competition in 2019.

The two were the most popular pairing from the first outing. Unfortunately, they didn’t stay together for long after leaving the villa and broke up citing they wanted different things. 

To see who will win this season, new episodes of Love Island USA are available for streaming six days a week on Peacock. 

Catch up on all the seasons of Love Island USA on Peacock