As another party winds down at the guy’s villa, Casey explains to Medinah that he doesn’t feel bad putting everyone in the house in the friend zone, and that he wouldn’t mind going back to his old bachelor lifestyle. “Honestly, if Ashley broke up with me, I’d be okay,” he says. Medinah is not impressed, and when Payton comes to join them, she tells her, “I solved the Casey puzzle. Casey is in fact an a**hole.” She encourages Casey to let his feelings “come through.”
Samantha Hoffman's time on Temptation Island may be over, but that doesn't mean that her journey is complete. We recently sat down with the bachelorette to ask her about her time on the show, the infamous threesome, and her connection with David Benavidez.