There's No "I" In Cream
S1 episode 9 Aired on April 24, 2014

During a question and answer session, the team gives a group of prospective new recruits a taste of the job and walks them through a shift from a few days prior. 

It starts as a day like any other, as Johnny, Hank and Brian run down the top three first ladies they’d sleep with.  Later, Johnny treats everyone to a dozen Bavarian cream donuts from a fancy donut shop, but when he steps away for a minute, he returns to find the box empty.  The question is, who took the last donut and didn’t save him one?  

To the team’s annoyance, Johnny spends the rest of the day trying to get to the bottom of the situation.  Along the way they search for a brand of gum that won’t lose its flavor, educate Brian on the seating hierarchy, and become a little bit closer as a work family, and save a few lives…