During his visit, Shawn figures out the money was supposed to go to Northcutt’s son, and that Northcutt had been trying to find an old church. Shawn then realizes that’s where the money is hidden. At the church, the team looks for the money. The team finds Northcutt there with the money, and is thankfully able to take him, along with his accomplice, down. But in a stunning turn of events, Craig points a gun on Shawn, Gus and the two inmates. Craig, distraught from losing his job, wants the money for himself. So he steals it from the inmates and makes an escape in the Blueberry. He is stopped shortly by Shawn and Gus. They plead with Craig not to take the money, and try to appeal to him on his level. Craig points the gun at Shawn and Gus and shoots—but Shawn and Gus aren’t hit—Craig ends up shooting and injuring an approaching Northcutt and his partner, Sanders.
Back at SBPD, Shawn and Gus lie on Craig’s behalf in order to get his job back. And as a result, Craig is given a reward for returning the stolen money. Shawn and Gus fully expect to get a little monetary pat on the back for not telling on Craig to the chief, but Craig decides to keep the money for himself.